Is Elmer’s glue as good as Mod Podge?

Are you a die-hard crafting enthusiast who’s always looking for ways to elevate your DIY projects? If so, you’ve probably stumbled upon the age-old debate of whether Elmer’s glue is as good as Mod Podge. The crafting community is split on this topic, with some swearing by one and others by the other. But what sets these two adhesives apart, and which one reigns supreme?

In this blog post, we’re delving deep into the world of crafting adhesives to uncover the truth. We’ll take an in-depth look at both Mod Podge and Elmer’s glue, examining their features, pros, and cons. We’ll also consider their application methods, drying times, and overall effectiveness.

But why is this debate even happening in the first place? After all, Mod Podge has been a go-to product in the crafting world for years. It’s specifically designed to attach paper and fabric to surfaces while sealing them in place. Meanwhile, Elmer’s glue is typically used for general-purpose projects in schools, homes, and offices. Yet many crafters swear by using Elmer’s glue as a cheaper alternative to Mod Podge.

So what’s the verdict? Is Elmer’s glue truly as good as Mod Podge or just another myth? Keep reading to find out which adhesive comes out on top.

What is Elmer’s Glue?

In the world of crafting and repairs, one name stands out above the rest: Elmer’s Glue. For over 70 years, this water-based polyvinyl acetate (PVA) adhesive has been a go-to for artists, woodworkers, and DIY enthusiasts alike. But what makes Elmer’s Glue so special?

First and foremost, Elmer’s Glue is incredibly versatile. With a range of formulas to choose from, it can be used in almost any project. Whether you need something lightweight for paper crafts or something heavy-duty for woodworking, there is an Elmer’s Glue formula that will get the job done.

The classic white glue is the most popular of all the formulas and is perfect for any paper crafting project. The school glue, which is non-toxic and safe for children to use, is another favorite among parents and teachers alike. Meanwhile, the clear glue provides a transparent finish that is ideal for projects where you don’t want any visible residue. And for those who want a bit of sparkle, Elmer’s offers a glitter glue option.

But that’s not all. Elmer’s also offers specialty glues such as wood and fabric glue. Their wood glue is perfect for woodworking projects as it creates a strong bond between two pieces of wood. Similarly, their fabric glue provides a permanent hold for fabrics.

One of the best things about Elmer’s Glue is its accessibility. You can find it in almost every store, and it won’t break the bank compared to other types of adhesives. Plus, it’s non-toxic and easy to clean up with water while still wet.

When compared to other popular crafting adhesives like Mod Podge, Elmer’s Glue has its own unique strengths and weaknesses. While Mod Podge may provide a more durable finish than Elmer’s Glue, it also requires multiple coats. Elmer’s Glue, on the other hand, may be thinner and easier to spread but may not provide as strong of a bond.

What is Mod Podge?

Crafters, listen up. If you’re seeking a versatile product that can provide a durable finish for your artwork and DIY projects, look no further than Mod Podge. This water-based sealer, glue, and finish is a staple in the arts and crafts world for good reason.

Mod Podge is a reliable and easy-to-use product that adheres well to a variety of surfaces, including paper, wood, fabric, and plastic. What’s more, it comes in different finishes – glossy, matte, and satin – to cater to your individual style preferences.

This wonder-product was created by Jan Wetstone, a crafter who was determined to find a better method of decoupaging than the messy glue and varnish process. Wetstone experimented with various ingredients until she discovered the perfect combination of adhesive and sealant – enter Mod Podge.

The secret to Mod Podge’s success lies in its composition. It’s made from a blend of water, PVA glue, and acrylic resin. The water dissolves the glue and resin, making it easy to apply. The PVA glue acts as an adhesive that sticks your material to the surface, while the acrylic resin provides a protective layer that seals and finishes your project.

What sets Mod Podge apart from other adhesives is its ability to provide an unrivaled durability and professional-looking finish. If you’re looking for a product that will stand the test of time, Mod Podge is the way to go.

Now, you might be wondering how Mod Podge compares to other adhesives like Elmer’s glue. While Elmer’s glue provides a strong bond, it may not have the same level of durability as Mod Podge. So if you’re after longevity and a professional finish, Mod Podge is undoubtedly the winner.

Comparison of Elmer’s Glue and Mod Podge

With so many types of glue available, it can be difficult to decide which one to use for your project. Two popular options that often get compared are Elmer’s glue and Mod Podge. Let’s dive into the differences between these two adhesives and help you decide which one is best for your project.

Elmer’s glue is a tried and true classic. This white school glue is a water-based adhesive that’s easy to clean up with soap and water. It’s known for its strong bonding capabilities and can be used on a variety of surfaces, from paper to cardboard to wood. If you’re working on a basic school project or simple craft like scrapbooking, Elmer’s glue is a great choice.

Mod Podge, on the other hand, is a decoupage medium that acts as both a glue and a sealer. Originally created for decoupage projects (which involve gluing paper cutouts onto a surface), Mod Podge is also water-based and can be cleaned up with soap and water. It dries clear and is perfect for more complex craft projects that involve multiple layers or need a sealant.

When deciding between these two adhesives, it’s important to consider what your project requires. If you’re doing something simple, Elmer’s glue is probably all you need. But if you’re working on a more intricate project that requires multiple layers or needs to be sealed, Mod Podge is likely the better choice.

Price may also be a factor in your decision-making process. Elmer’s glue is generally less expensive than Mod Podge, but keep in mind that Mod Podge can serve multiple purposes in one project. So even though it may cost more upfront, it could end up being more cost-effective in the long run.

Advantages of Elmer’s Glue

As an expert on the advantages of Elmer’s glue, I can confidently say that it has numerous benefits that make it a top choice for creatives.

One of the most significant advantages of Elmer’s glue is its affordability. Unlike other craft glues such as Mod Podge, Elmer’s glue is much cheaper and accessible in most stores. This aspect makes it a fantastic option for those on a tight budget.

Furthermore, Elmer’s glue is incredibly versatile. It can be used for various projects ranging from paper crafts to cardboard projects and even some woodwork. Its non-toxic and washable nature also makes it safe for kids’ crafts, making it an ideal choice for family crafting sessions.

In addition to its versatility, Elmer’s glue dries clear, making it perfect for projects where the glue should not be visible. This feature is especially critical for paper crafts and scrapbooking as it allows the focus to remain on the project instead of the adhesive.

Lastly, Elmer’s glue can be easily thinned with water to create a consistency similar to Mod Podge without having to purchase a separate product. This quality makes it an excellent choice for decoupage projects.

Advantages of Mod Podge

Is Elmer's glue as good as Mod Podge-2

With its versatility and ability to adhere to various surfaces, Mod Podge is the go-to adhesive for all types of crafting projects.

One of the biggest advantages of Mod Podge is its exceptional durability. Unlike Elmer’s glue, Mod Podge is designed to withstand wear and tear, making it perfect for items that are frequently handled or exposed to the elements. Moreover, its clear drying properties leave behind a smooth and professional-looking finish that will make your projects stand out.

Is Elmer's glue as good as Mod Podge-3

Another advantage of Mod Podge is its ability to act as an excellent sealant. When applied over paper or other porous materials, Mod Podge creates a protective barrier that helps to preserve their integrity, preventing them from yellowing or fading over time. This makes it an excellent choice for scrapbooking, decoupage, and other paper-based crafts.

In addition to its durability and sealing properties, Mod Podge comes in a variety of formulas that cater to different project needs. Whether you’re looking for a glossy or matte finish, there’s a Mod Podge formula for every project type. Furthermore, specific options are available that are designed for use on fabric or outdoor surfaces, making it a versatile adhesive for all types of crafting projects.

Finally, one of the most significant advantages of Mod Podge is its ease of use. Unlike some other adhesives that can be messy or difficult to work with, Mod Podge is easy to apply and dries quickly. It can be used with a brush or sponge applicator, and any excess can be wiped away with water before it dries.

Disadvantages of Elmer’s Glue

When it comes to crafting, Elmer’s glue is a go-to adhesive for many. However, before you embark on your next project with this popular craft glue, it’s important to know its disadvantages compared to Mod Podge.

One significant drawback of Elmer’s glue is its tendency to yellow over time. This yellowing effect can be especially problematic for long-lasting projects or those that will be displayed in bright light. Exposure to heat and humidity can also exacerbate the yellowing process.

Another issue with Elmer’s glue is its water-solubility. While this feature can be an advantage in certain projects, it also means that the glue can easily break down or become distorted when exposed to moisture or humidity. This limits the types of projects for which Elmer’s glue is suitable and may not provide the same level of protection against wear and tear as Mod Podge.

Furthermore, Elmer’s glue is not as durable as Mod Podge, making it less suitable for heavy use or wear and tear projects. It may not hold up well against scratches, scuffs, or fading, which can ultimately lead to disappointment after putting in hours of hard work.

Disadvantages of Mod Podge

Crafting is a fun and exciting way to express your creativity, but it’s important to know the potential drawbacks of the materials you’re using. Mod Podge, a popular adhesive in the crafting world, has been around for decades and has its advantages, but it also comes with some disadvantages.

One major downside of Mod Podge is that it can leave a sticky residue on surfaces. This can be especially frustrating if you’re using it on a surface that needs to be cleaned easily or used for food or drink. The residue can attract dirt and grime, making the surface look unattractive even after cleaning. If you’re looking for a clean finish, Mod Podge might not be your best option.

Another disadvantage of Mod Podge is its difficulty in removal once applied. This can be problematic if you make a mistake or need to make changes to your project. Removing Mod Podge may require harsh chemicals that can damage the surface underneath, so it’s essential to apply it carefully and only where necessary.

Moreover, Mod Podge can cause wrinkles or bubbles when used on certain materials like paper or fabric. This can be frustrating and time-consuming, possibly leading to redoing parts of your project. If you’re working with delicate materials, consider testing out different glues before committing to Mod Podge.

Lastly, Mod Podge can be more expensive than other types of glue such as Elmer’s glue. While it has unique properties that make it useful for certain crafts, it may not always be worth the extra cost. So, if you’re on a tight budget, consider trying out some cheaper alternatives.

Which One Should You Choose?

Elmer’s glue is a popular choice for school projects and simple crafts. Not only is it easy to find in most stores, but it also comes in a variety of formulas, including washable, clear, and glitter. Plus, it’s an affordable option that dries clear, making it perfect for projects where appearance isn’t crucial.

On the other hand, Mod Podge is a more versatile product that can be used for a wider range of projects. As a type of decoupage glue, it can serve as both a sealer and adhesive. Additionally, it’s available in various formulas such as matte, glossy, and outdoor. This fantastic product dries clear and can be used on numerous surfaces such as paper, wood, fabric, and plastic.

When deciding between the two options, consider the requirements of your specific project. If you’re working on a simple craft or school project where appearance isn’t essential, Elmer’s glue may be the better choice due to its affordability and availability. However, suppose you’re working on a more complex project or using multiple materials. In that case, Mod Podge may be the more versatile option to fulfill your creative needs.

x0XTqLN4hKQ” >

Also Read: Is there a Mod Podge Alternative? – Glue Things


After much debate and consideration, it’s clear that the question of whether Elmer’s glue can match up to Mod Podge is a difficult one to answer. Both adhesives have their own unique strengths and weaknesses, making it challenging to declare a clear winner.

Elmer’s glue is an excellent choice for those on a budget or looking for a versatile adhesive that can be used on various materials. It dries clear and is perfect for projects where appearance isn’t crucial. However, it may not offer the same level of durability as Mod Podge when it comes to wear and tear.

Mod Podge, on the other hand, is known for its exceptional durability and professional-looking finish that can withstand even the toughest conditions. It’s also more versatile than Elmer’s glue as it can serve as both a sealer and adhesive. However, removing it from surfaces once applied can be tricky.

Ultimately, choosing between Elmer’s glue or Mod Podge depends on your specific project requirements. If you’re working on a simple craft or school project where appearance isn’t critical, Elmer’s glue may be the better option due to its affordability and easy accessibility. However, if you’re working on a more complex project or using multiple materials that require extra protection against wear and tear, Mod Podge may be the more versatile choice to meet your creative needs.

In conclusion, both adhesives have their unique advantages depending on what you need them for.